Liberators Criminal Defense

Why you should never talk to police without a lawyer

If police want to talk to you, whether as a suspect, a witness, or someone 'just being asked a few questions,' the safest thing you can do is say nothing until your attorney is present. Innocent people talk themselves into criminal charges every day.

5.0

16 Google reviews

"

Michael Mee is one of the best lawyers in town. I would highly recommend him. He was very attentive to my case from day one and we won.

— Elias Manolopoulos
Free consultation →

How honest people end up charged with crimes

What you say

I was nearby but I wasn't involved

What they write in the report

He placed himself at the scene

What you say

I don't remember exactly

What they write in the report

His story is inconsistent, a sign of deception

What you say

Wait, that's not what I meant. Let me explain

What they write in the report

He's changing his story under pressure

What you say

I had nothing to do with it

What they write in the report

Flat denial despite evidence; not credible

What you say

I want to cooperate and tell you everything

What they write in the report

He waived his rights voluntarily

Everything you say becomes evidence, and none of it helps you. The detective's report paraphrases your words, organizes them into a narrative, and presents them to the DA. You do not get to review the report. You do not get to correct it. The jury reads it as your words.

Why talking is dangerous even if you are innocent

Police are legally allowed to lie to you

Officers can claim they have evidence they do not have, that a co-defendant confessed when they did not, or that your DNA was found at the scene when it was not. These are approved interrogation techniques designed to provoke a reaction. If you do not know this, you are negotiating in the dark.

Miranda does not protect voluntary conversations

If you walk into the station on your own, you are not in custody, so Miranda does not apply. Police can question you for hours without reading your rights, and every word you say is admissible. The 'friendly chat' is the riskiest kind of interrogation because it comes with none of those protections.

Memory is imperfect, and they know it

You will not remember every detail perfectly. Normal memory gaps (what time you left, which route you took, what you were wearing) become 'inconsistencies' in the detective's report. Inconsistencies become 'deception indicators.' And suddenly your imperfect memory is evidence of guilt.

You cannot 'un-say' something

Once a statement is made, it exists forever. It goes in the report, it gets quoted in the charging document, it gets read to the jury. Your attorney can try to suppress it or explain it, but the damage of a bad statement is real and lasting. Silence creates no evidence. Words create permanent evidence.

What to do instead

01

Identify yourself and nothing more

Provide your name and ID if asked. You are legally required to identify yourself. You are not required to explain, describe, narrate, or discuss anything else.

02

Say one sentence

"I am exercising my right to remain silent and I want to speak with an attorney." Once you say it in custody, all questioning must stop. Say it clearly. Say it once. Then stop talking.

03

Do not try to explain or 'clear things up'

Every additional word is a risk. Do not fill the silence. Do not respond to provocative statements. Do not correct the detective's assumptions. Staying quiet is not rude. It is your right.

04

Call a defense attorney

Your attorney evaluates the situation, decides whether any communication with police is in your interest, and if so, controls the terms: what is said, when, and with what protections in place. Your attorney speaks for you.

Silence on your own can feel awkward.

Silence through a lawyer is routine.

Sitting quietly across from a detective is hard. Having a retained attorney tell police you will not be answering questions is easy, and it ends the conversation. Get the attorney first.

Talking to police: common questions

Common questions about your right to remain silent and police interrogation in Nevada.

Frequently asked questions

Yes. The Fifth Amendment protects your right to remain silent. You are not required to answer questions, explain yourself, or 'clear things up.' You must identify yourself if asked (name and ID), but beyond that, you can decline to answer every question. Say: 'I am exercising my right to remain silent and I want to speak with an attorney.' Then stop talking.
In the hallway, maybe. In the courtroom, no. A jury is specifically instructed that they cannot hold your silence against you. Silence cannot be used as evidence of guilt at trial. Your words can be used as evidence of guilt, even if they were honest, confused, or taken out of context. Silence protects you, and talking creates risk.
That is the usual opening. Detectives are trained to make the conversation feel casual, low-stakes, and cooperative. The goal is to get you talking before you think to ask for a lawyer. There is no legal obligation to 'clear something up.' If you are not under arrest, you can leave. If you are under arrest, you can remain silent. Either way, the answer is the same: call an attorney first.
If you are not under arrest, no. A 'request' to come to the station is not a legal order. You can decline. If detectives show up at your door, you can speak through the door and decline to let them in. If they have a warrant or arrest you, comply physically, but still exercise your right to remain silent and ask for an attorney.
Not necessarily. What you said, when you said it, and whether Miranda warnings should have been given all affect the answer. Your attorney can evaluate the circumstances and determine whether your statements can be challenged: through a motion to suppress for Miranda violations, through arguments about voluntariness, or through cross-examination of the officers about how the interview was conducted. Talking to police is bad. It is not always fatal.
Yes. Police are legally allowed to lie to you during questioning. They can say they have evidence they do not have, that a co-defendant confessed when they did not, that they found your DNA at the scene when they did not. These techniques are designed to provoke reactions: confessions, contradictions, or statements that can be used against you. Knowing this is one more reason to say nothing without an attorney.
If you are in custody and you clearly invoke your right to an attorney, all questioning must stop immediately. Police cannot resume interrogation until your attorney is present, unless you voluntarily start the conversation again. Asking for a lawyer is the single most useful thing you can say during a police encounter. Once you say it, the interrogation is over.
Probably not. Miranda (the requirement that police warn you of your rights) only applies when you are in custody and being interrogated. If you walk into the station voluntarily, you are not in custody, which means police can question you at length without reading your rights, and everything you say is admissible. This is exactly why voluntary conversations with police are so dangerous. You get none of the protections and all of the risk.
Usually not. Unless the interview is recorded, the detective writes a summary from memory, paraphrasing your words, organizing the conversation into a narrative, and presenting it in a way that supports the investigation. You will not get to review or approve the report. The DA reads it as fact. A jury reads it as your words. And it may not accurately reflect what you actually said or meant.
Only when your attorney has reviewed the situation and determined that a specific, limited communication serves your interests, and only under conditions your attorney controls. That might mean a written statement, a proffer session with immunity terms, or a conversation with your attorney present. It never means walking into the station alone because you think the truth will set you free.

Police want to talk to you?

Call Michael Mee first. He can be present for any interview, advise you on whether to speak at all, and make sure nothing you say is used to build a case against you. Free consultation. Call or text 702-990-0190.

Call 702-990-0190Text us

Related

Tap any topic for the full guide.

Miranda rights and DUIYour constitutional rightsIllegal search and seizureWithdrawing consent to a searchHow evidence gets excludedCan bail be deniedWhat to expect at arraignmentCriminal defenseRecord sealing

Page last updated . Written by Michael Mee, Nevada Bar No. 13726.

Talk to a Nevada criminal defense lawyer today

(702) 990-0190
Schedule a free consultation
Call 702-990-0190Text